News Article

Valuing a share in a house after a legal dispute outside marriage

Valuing a share in a house after a legal dispute outside marriage can be complicated because the court first needs to find as a fact that there was an agreement to create an interest in the house under a trust that is not reflected in the legal title at the Land Registry. Northwich solicitors Stonehewer Moss recommend that efforts are made to at least agree the valuation of the share even if you cannot agree the factual dispute that there was such an agreement. The Cheshire family law specialists offer collaborative law as an option outside of Court and can refer cases to  mediation. Michael Brennan is the accredited family law solicitor at the firm and considers efforts to narrow the issues to the basic factual dispute can help reduce the cost of court disputes for cohabitants, as the relatively self contained process developed for divorce is not available. Michael says,” There is no access to the divorce courts if you have no marriage certificate, regardless of your relationship being as long if not longer than many marriages. The divorce court can distribute assets. The civil court is not on the face of it allowed to adjust ownership but reading the latest appeal called Sandhu v Sandhu 2016 certainly indicates the court has a degree of latitude once it has established there is a trust interest. I set out an extract from Sandhu that refers to the leading authorities but seems to warn that a one size fits all approach is mistaken. Civil claims involve costs orders against the loser and uncertainty creates higher legal bills, so negotiating what the interest should be if the court finds against you may be a sensible if uncomfortable precaution.”

The Judgment in Sandhu provides “The judge directed herself by reference to the decision of the Supreme Court  Jones v Kernott. She said that since the evidence did not show what particular shares were intended, she had to consider all the evidence as to the whole course of dealing between Bill and his father in relation to the property, including the financial contributions, in arriving at a fair result. No criticism is made by either side of the judge’s legal approach on this appeal. I would add that the exercise is not a rigidly arithmetical one: see, for example, per Baroness Hale of Richmond in Stack v Dowden “

Valuing a share in a house after a legal dispute outside marriage is best approached out of court to resolve as much of the case as does not require a finding on the facts by the Court.

For advice negotiation and representation in cohabitation disputes please call 01606 872200 or e mail visit



Watch our videos

For more information about how we can help you with your claim, call us on 01606 87 22 00, or email us at

The Personal Injury Team

Our team are dedicated to achiving the best possible outcome for our clients. Read more here

Dominic Moss

Senior Partner

Dominic Moss Personal Injury Solicitor 87 22 00

Sarah Allison

Partner 87 22 00

Thomas Owen


Tom Owen Personal Injury Lawyer 87 22 00

Julie Capper

Office Administrator 87 22 00

What our clients say about us

Rate Stonehewermoss Solicitors

Stonehewer Moss Solicitors, Citadel House, Solvay Road, Northwich, Cheshire, CW8 4DP

Solicitors in Northwich covering Chester, Crewe, Knutsford, Macclesfield, Middlewich, Northwich, Runcorn, Sandbach, Warrington, Winsford, and across Cheshire.

Stonehewer Moss Solicitors is a trading style of the Stonehewer Moss Limited, Registered in England No. 542 6583 and PIPLaw
which is a firm of solicitors authorised and regulated by the the Solicitors Regulation Authority No. 471159

Contact Us

Contact Us

To get in touch simply fill out the short form below and we will reply very shortly, and definitely within 24 hours. The online enquiry form is completely safe and secure, and your details will not be available to anyone other than Stonehewer Moss Solicitors.

Contact Form

Get in touch today!

Complete the form below and we'll get back to you as soon as possible to help you with your enquiry. Your personal details are never shared or sold.

Alternatively, call us on 01606 87 22 00, or email us at

This website uses Cookies to improve your browsing experience and to help with our marketing. You can read more about removing Cookies here.

I'm fine with this